A few weeks ago, I explained why trade associations like the American Chemistry Council have a duty to speak out about Union Pacific’s proposed merger with Norfolk Southern, particularly when individual companies may be reluctant to publicly challenge a railroad they depend on.
Now we have a striking example of why.
A newly released video shows Union Pacific CEO Jim Vena telling rail customers that if the merger failed, he would “probably increase everybody’s rates” who opposed it by another 3 or 4 percent “to teach you a lesson.”
Jim Vena crossed the line when he suggested Union Pacific would pick winners and losers based on which customers supported its merger. Union Pacific says the remark was a joke. But when one of America’s largest freight railroads talks about raising rates on customers who oppose its merger, customers have every reason to pay attention – and take them at their word.
And so should regulators.
This episode is especially troubling because Union Pacific has repeatedly tried to sideline critics of its merger and questioned whether trade associations representing rail customers should have a voice in the debate.
The railroad has consistently and repeatedly resisted greater scrutiny of its proposal. In January, the Surface Transportation Board unanimously rejected the original merger application as incomplete because it lacked required information, including adequate projected market share information and portions of the merger agreement. When the revised application was accepted, the Board still ordered Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern to provide supplemental information because parts of the proposal remained “unclear or underdeveloped.”
More recently, Richard Kloster, the newest member of the Surface Transportation Board, said there has been a “lack of transparency and depth” in the application and concluded that the railroads “still have a long way to go” to demonstrate that their merger is in the public interest
Then Union Pacific fought to keep the Vena video of a public event under wraps. The full Board ultimately rejected that effort, ordered the video made public and directed the railroad to provide additional information related to allegations of retaliation. Now we know why Union Pacific fought so hard to keep these revealing comments from public view.
That brings us back to why organizations like ACC matter.
Many chemical manufacturers depend on freight rail to move essential products. Individual companies should never have to choose between speaking honestly about a merger that could affect their business and protecting an important commercial relationship.
When individual companies face retaliation, associations like ACC are vital to standing up for our members.
Our members have asked ACC to oppose this merger because they believe further consolidation will mean less competition, fewer choices and greater risks for American manufacturing and supply chains. Rail customers need competition and choice, not threats for speaking out against a bad deal.
Union Pacific can try to silence its critics, but it won’t silence us. When our members’ interests are at stake, ACC will make sure their voices are heard.